Bond market risk appetites hold the key to the stock market right now. It is normally the case that equity and debt markets are very closely intertwined but today this true more than ever. And the bond market is signaling the party is nearly over.
I say that the relationship between bonds and stocks is more important today than ever because mergers and acquisitions activity and stock buybacks have been a major source of demand for equities over the past few years. And, to a very large degree, these have been financed by debt. So companies’ ability to access the credit markets currently has a huge impact on stock prices.
Ray Dalio says buybacks/M&A now make up 70% of all the buying volume in stocks. Anyone have data to back this up? http://t.co/JMMkR7bf5g
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) September 24, 2015
This is evident in the fact that, after shunning corporate bonds in September, investors rushed back into the sector in October. Stocks clearly benefitted, seeing one of the largest one-month rallies in quite some time.
Bloomberg: Record inflows into corporate bond ETFs last month https://t.co/dTp3Qf1Lb4 pic.twitter.com/gLgS7TtcSd
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
The Wall Street Journal reports that the rebound in October puts the corporate bond market back on track for another record year of issuance.
WSJ: Bond market risk appetites return in October https://t.co/H8N4rIJGxV pic.twitter.com/I1T31mP01G
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
Despite the record investor demand for these funds, however, the interest rate spread between corporate bonds and treasuries hasn’t narrowed very much at all over the past month. This means that the cost of pursuing buybacks and M&A through new debt issuance is still more expensive than just a few months ago, let alone a year ago.
Is this all the narrowing in spreads we get after record corporate bond fund inflows? pic.twitter.com/axrSBWHyJn
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
The persistence in spreads may simply be a sign that companies are reaching the limits of their ability to borrow and spend on buybacks and M&A. The ratings agencies are clearly signaling their concern in this regard.
Bloomberg: This is the first year since 2009 downgrades are significantly outpacing upgrades https://t.co/rcH6ruYe74 pic.twitter.com/beWi1GMMTJ
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
Indeed, corporate leverage has soared far past the peak seen prior to the financial crisis. What’s more, after falling to very low levels defaults are now starting to grow again.
Bloomberg: Corporate leverage is off the charts and defaults are starting to rise https://t.co/tx1yRNHMh1 pic.twitter.com/Em2pRkERMf
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
And with the global economy slowing, in many ways back to recessionary levels, it’s hard to imagine how these trends will reverse themselves.
Bloomberg: Global bond markets signal growth and inflation will remain tepid for years https://t.co/sCjp4ZFZos pic.twitter.com/nfrqrMhiRK
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
Finally, it appears that the stock market may have overreacted to the rebound in the corporate bond market. Bonds, as measured by risk appetites, are still pricing in much more fear than stocks currently do.
Still a massive disparity between fear in stocks versus bonds: pic.twitter.com/YetxNnNsmj
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
When this has happened in the past, it’s not been a good sign for the stock market.
.@sentimentrader quantified the divergence between bond/stock fear on Friday (hint: bonds are usually right): pic.twitter.com/LMECRHsBjp
— Jesse Felder (@jessefelder) November 2, 2015
Ultimately, it looks like we are in the very late innings of this credit cycle. Companies have now levered up to an unprecedented degree and downgrades and defaults are rising from very depressed levels. Spreads have also now been widening for over a year. Should these trends continue, more and more companies will begin to find it difficult to access the credit markets. And because buybacks and M&A have become such a critical component of the bull market in equities, the potential end of the credit cycle could mean precisely the same for the equity cycle.